15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (2024)

If you’re looking for homemade Christmas candy that’s sugar free, we’ve got you covered!

These sugar free Christmas candy recipes are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth this holiday season, but without the guilt!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (1)

Note: This post may contain affiliate links for your convenience. You can read my full disclosure policy here.

If you’ve ever tried to stick to a special diet or eating plan, you know how difficult the holidays can be.

Whether you have food allergies, are trying to lose weight, or simply want to maintain a healthier lifestyle, the plethora of sweets served at Christmas time can certainly make it difficult.

Because it’s important that everyone is able enjoy the holiday season without feeling deprived, we’re sharing some sugar-free candy recipes that are perfect for Christmas!

Whether you’re trying to maintain a low carb lifestyle, are following the keto diet, are simply watching your sugar intake, or are diabetic, these sugar free Christmas candy recipes are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

We’re sharing easy candy recipes, including delicious chocolate treats, fudge, truffles, peppermint bark, peanut butter cups, crockpot peanut clusters, white chocolate bark, and more of your favorite candies!

Related: Try my sugar free banana bread for Christmas morning breakfast!

Ingredients and Supplies For Making Christmas Candies without Sugar:

When it comes to making your favorite treats without sugar, it’s important to have some good substitutes on hand. That can make all the difference!

Many of these recipes rely on sugar free versions of traditional holiday baking and cooking staples.

A few simple ingredients you may want to keep on hand during the holidays are:

Sugar Free Homemade Christmas Candy

We know you’ll love these sugar free candies this Christmas season!

Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes

Whether you need options for diabetic family members or simply prefer low carb options, we're sharing our favorite sugar free Christmas candy recipes with you!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (2)

Photo Credit:thebestketorecipes.com

Keto Crockpot Candy (Chocolate Peanut Clusters)

These clusters make use of sugar free chocolate chips, so you can enjoy a simple yet delicious combo of chocolate, peanut butter, and peanuts!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (3)

Photo Credit:myproductivebackyard.com

Sugar Free Peppermint Fudge

Nothing says Christmas like peppermint! Skip the regular powdered sugar traditionally used in fudge and and use Swerve confectioner's sugar instead!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (4)

Photo Credit:ketocookingchristian.com

Sugar Free Pecan Praline Bark

Chocolate lovers need not despair--this pecan praline bark is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (6)

Photo Credit:healthywithjamie.com

Easy Keto Chocolate Fudge Recipe

This chocolage fudge recipe is sugar free, dairy free, and gluten-free, making it a great edible gift idea for those in your life with special dietary needs!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (7)

Photo Credit:www.sugarfreemom.com

No Bake Sugar-Free Peppermint Patty Bites

These sugar free peppermint patty bites are adorably festive--and delicious! The perfect sugar free addition to a cookie tray or dessert table this year.

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (8)

Photo Credit:onewholesomelife.com

Keto Christmas Crack

Christmas "Crack" is a holiday classic, and this version makes a few healthy swaps. Brown sugar Swerve, almond flour crackers, and sugar-free chocolate chips help you still enjoy your favorite Christmas treat without the guilt.

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (9)

Photo Credit:www.lowcarbmaven.com

Sugar Free Chocolate Truffles

You can make a variety of these sugar free chocolate truffles, rolling them in finely chopped nuts, cocoa powder, crushed sugar-free peppermints, and more!

These nut clusters are easy to put together and are the perfect crunchy candy option for your holiday guests!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (11)

Photo Credit:healthyindulgences.net

Sugar Free Buckeyes

Buckeyes are a quintessential Christmas dessert in the Midwest, and you can still enjoy them with this sugar free recipe!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (12)

Photo Credit:www.sugarfreemom.com

Sugar-Free White Chocolate Bars

How pretty are these sugar free white chocolate bars? Add in your favorite nuts, dried fruits, and more!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (13)

Photo Credit:kicking-carbs.com

Sugar-Free Peppermint Bark

Not only does peppermint bark make a festive dessert or snack, but it also makes a fantastic gift! This sugar free version is great for diabetics or those following a keto or low-carb lifestyle.

It's hard to believe these chocolate covered buttercreams are sugar free! The creamy centers pair perfectly with the chocolate coating.

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (15)

Photo Credit:castleinthemountains.com

Sugar Free Highland Toffee

This Highland Toffee recipe uses allulose for sweetness, paired with butter, sugar free chocolate chips, and your choice of nuts!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (16)

Photo Credit:www.sugarfreemom.com

Sugar-Free Copycat Ferrero Rocher

If you know the glory that is Ferrero Rocher candies, you'll love that you can enjoy a sugar free version! Creamy chocolate pairs with hazelnuts for a delightful treat.

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (17)

Photo Credit:lowcarbhoser.com

Sugar Free Cream Cheese Mints

Commonly referred to as "wedding mints," these cream cheese mints use Swerve powdered sugar to keep them sugar free. Use red and green food coloring for a festive flair!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (18)

Photo Credit:thebigmansworld.com

Sugar Free Hard Candy

If hard candies are more your style, learn how to make them without sugar!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (19)

Photo Credit:thebigmansworld.com

Sugar Free Candied Pecans

Candied pecans make a great snack or an addition to a salad. You can also give them as gifts!

Purchasing Sugar Free Christmas Candy

Maybe you need some low carb candies to fill your candy dishes or to use as stocking stuffers.

If you’re looking for some sugar free candies to purchase, these are some classics to add to your pantry this Christmas:

More Holiday Recipe Suggestions:

  • Make homemade hot chocolate with chocolate chips. Use sugar-free chocolate chips and Swerve or Lakanto powdered sugar to keep it sugar free!
  • You can make dairy free hot chocolate with oat milk, using Lakanto monkfruit sweetener instead of sugar.
  • Enjoy Scottish shortbread by using Swerve or Lakanto powdered sugar.

Be sure to save this list to your Christmas recipes board on Pinterest!

15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (20)
15+ Sugar Free Christmas Candy Recipes (2024)

FAQs

Is sugar-free candy ok for diabetics? ›

Yes, children and adults with diabetes can and do eat candy. The key is moderation and making sure to track the number of carbohydrates and calories eaten. Sugar-free candies can be better for blood sugar levels, but they still contain carbs and calories.

Can we make candy without sugar? ›

Jaggery is always a perfect and healthy replacement for sugar, Jaggery candies are simple to prepare and they just need three easily available ingredients. These jaggery candies are a concoction of ginger and honey which works as medicine for cough, let's make tasty medicines here we go!!

Why is sugar-free candy so expensive? ›

Manufacturers charge more for these products because they use synthetics that cost more to source. It's difficult to make candy that tastes good without sugar.

What is the healthiest hard candy? ›

If you prefer hard candy over chewy, grab a bag of Dr. John's hard candy. These sugar-free candies are tooth-friendly and a great choice for those with diabetes (as are these chocolate recipes you won't believe are diabetic-friendly). These candies are also allergy-friendly, so everyone can enjoy them.

Does sugar free candy raise a1c? ›

It's true that sugar alcohols such as sorbitol, xylitol, and mannitol, don't affect blood sugars as dramatically as other carbohydrates do. So sugar-free candy with most of the total carbs coming from these alcohols will typically have less impact on your blood sugar.

What is the safest sugar substitute for diabetics? ›

5 Sugar Substitute Ideas for People With Diabetes
  1. Stevia. While you can buy stevia sweetener packets, it also grows as a plant — and some websites make harvesting and drying your own look easy. ...
  2. Coconut Palm Sugar. ...
  3. Erythritol. ...
  4. Advantame. ...
  5. Yacon Syrup.

What is a good substitute for sugar in candy? ›

Some sugar substitutes you'll see on labels include:
  • Saccharin.
  • Aspartame.
  • Sucralose.
  • Sugar alcohols such as erythritol, xylitol, maltitol, lactitol, and sorbitol.
Dec 20, 2023

Can diabetics eat twizzlers? ›

Twizzlers, 2 Strawberry Twists These are almost pure sugar. “Sometimes people with diabetes want to use their favorite candy to treat a low blood sugar incident,” says Norwood. “It's permission to eat sugar when they otherwise feel they shouldn't be eating it regularly.” Carbohydrate count: 18 g.

What is a good substitute for sugar in candy making? ›

Natural plant sources, such as stevia and monk fruit, or artificial sweeteners such as aspartame, acesulfame potassium, or sucralose, can be used. Common bulking agents that are used with plant-based sources include erythritol, allulose, fiber, and maltodextrin.

Are Werthers sugar-free? ›

Although hard candies are where our story began, we also make indulgent soft caramels, long lasting chewy caramels, and No Sugar Added caramels.

Is sugar or aspartame worse? ›

“Really, both sugar and artificial sweeteners are a problem for your health,” says functional medicine specialist Melissa Young, MD. “But if we're comparing what's worse, artificial sweeteners are far worse than sugar.”

What is the most expensive sugar candy? ›

A 1.5-ounce bar of To'ak is the most expensive sugary bite you will ever take. And it contains only two ingredients: cacao and cane sugar. The thing is that the cacao in this candy comes from 100-year-old Arriba cacao trees, widely thought to be the last of the species.

What is the unhealthiest candy bar? ›

Here are the top five candy bars to avoid:
  • 3 Musketeers.
  • Milky Way.
  • Baby Ruth.
  • Chocolatey PayDay. They're like a normal PayDay bar wrapped in chocolate.
  • Mr. Goodbar.
Oct 8, 2020

What is the most unhealthy candy for your teeth? ›

Chewy/sticky sweets: Gummy candies, taffy, and even dried fruit can be difficult for children and adults to resist, but they are a serious source of tooth decay, particularly when they get stuck in the crevices between teeth and make it nearly impossible for saliva to wash away.

What is the safest candy for your teeth? ›

Chocolate: Chocolate is considered the safest overall candy for your child's teeth. This is fortunate because it is also the most popular, even if it's messier than the others on the list.

What kind of candy can a diabetic eat? ›

If you have diabetes, a great alternative to regular candy is sugar-free candy, as it typically has a decreased effect on your blood sugar levels. Some sugar substitutes that can be found in certain sugar-free candies include: stevia. aspartame.

Why does sugar-free candy raise my blood sugar? ›

If the candy contains sugar alcohols, as sugar-free candy often does, it still has the potential to affect your blood sugar levels, Taylor notes. That's because sugar alcohols have carbohydrates, too, just to a lesser degree than regular sugar.

Is anything sugar-free good for diabetics? ›

Used in moderation, artificial sweeteners can be safe for people with diabetes, and they can be used to reduce both your calorie and carbohydrate intake,” explains diabetes educator Sue Cotey, RN, CDCES. “Sugar substitutes also can help curb those cravings you have for something sweet.”

What type of candy can a Type 2 diabetic eat? ›

Diabetes Candy Exchanges
M&Ms, plain or peanut1 fun size bag
Twix bar1 fun size
Starburst4 pieces
Mars, Milky Way, or Three Musketeers1 fun size
Hershey Kisses or Hugs5 pieces
12 more rows

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duane Harber

Last Updated:

Views: 6707

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duane Harber

Birthday: 1999-10-17

Address: Apt. 404 9899 Magnolia Roads, Port Royceville, ID 78186

Phone: +186911129794335

Job: Human Hospitality Planner

Hobby: Listening to music, Orienteering, Knapping, Dance, Mountain biking, Fishing, Pottery

Introduction: My name is Duane Harber, I am a modern, clever, handsome, fair, agreeable, inexpensive, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.